The virtue of charity is a gift of God, a mark of the indwelling of the Holy Spirit, the badge of identity by which the followers of Christ will be known.
The virtue of justice is a more modest affair. If charity is the meat of the Christian life, justice is the milk, the basic elements of the oracles of God for those who are not yet skilled in the word of righteousness. We can hardly claim to have digested the solid food given to the mature in Christ when we can't even swallow the milk.
But simple, natural, elementary justice is in short supply. We are eager to believe terrible things about those with whom we disagree about politics or church affairs. We credit stories about them that, if told about someone we liked, we would see through immediately. We never ask ourselves the simple questions that someone who is seeking to be just is perpetually asking -- and someone who is reliably just asks and answers almost without thought, with virtuosity and flair: questions like, "Would I find this criticism cogent if it were directed against a friend? Would I credit a rumor this thinly sourced if it were being spread about an ally? Do I hold those who attack my
opponents to the same standards of evidence and argument that I demand from those who attack my friends?"
We lament sometimes the lack of charity that is shown in our current unpleasantness. That's like lamenting a bad score on the SAT when it turns out we've never even learned to read.
Labels: Acknowledge and bewail, The current unpleasantness